|
By M. A.
Salgado and L. Serra
Portugal is a Southwest European
country which benefits from its temperate climate, with
average temperatures in winter of 9-14 C and 20-30 C in
summer and from an extensive coastline, the west coast ca. 600
km and the south coast ca. 200 km, facing the Atlantic Ocean.
It is not surprising though, that seaside activity are
specially practised in particular sun bathing. From June to
September the official bathing season starts and brings maybe
50% of the population to the beaches.
Many industries need a place on the coast to settle such as
oil refinery plants and their treated or untreated wastewaters
are thrown into the sea. Besides industry, urban areas
expanded towards the coastal zone and consequently the
coastline has received an increasing pressure of organic load
and pollutants.
It is well known, at present, that
many beaches do not fulfil the requirements for health safety
due mainly to pollution from industries and domestic sewage
outfall from the cities. Sewage water treatment plants are
insufficient to treat the organic load from the cities and
villages and the wastes end up in the sea.
Some beaches in the north part of
Portugal have sewage wastewater running through their sands
because the sewage water pipelines are poorly maintained or in
other cases do not exist at all. Freshwater streams also
contribute to the contamination of the sands in the beach.
Aterro Beach is one of these beaches located about 8 km
northwards of Porto at Leça da Palmeira, close to an oil
refinery plant. A water stream coming from land and running
into the sea crosses the beach. It was in this stream that an
oil slick was observed. The sands in the stream bed were
black, the stream water had a sheen of oil and on the edge of
the stream, black sediments laid below 1 cm of white sands. It
becomes high priority to monitor these areas to protect human
health and the marine life.
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)
represent a relatively small percentage, of petroleum
constituents, their presence in fuel is fundamental to make
the combustion inside the vehicle’s engines to become less
explosive and more efficient [1], however some PAHs are known
by their toxicity and carcinogenicity to mammals and aquatic
life. They have been designated as priority pollutants by the
American Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). As the name
suggests, these compounds are cyclic, made of benzene rings
linked together, the simplest PAH has two rings, naphthalene,
and the complexity increases with the number of rings attached
to the molecule. Their physical/chemical properties are
important features, which determine their fate and behaviour
in the different components of the ecosystem, water, sands or
living organisms. They are water insoluble due to their low
polarity and in consequence they can be found adsorbed onto
sediments or surfaces and they are also prone to be taken up
by organisms. The simpler PAHs are volatile and are the first
to disappear from an oil spill when it sets fire, but the more
complex ones with higher molecular weights they are persistent
in the environment. They have very slow rates of microbial
degradation and can be accumulated in the sediments for long
time or in the tissues of living organisms. They enter through
the cellular membranes of organisms and can be transferred and
magnified through the food chain when taken by the predators.
The effects of polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons in living organisms, particularly in marine
mussels have been described as direct effects such as narcosis
of the cilia and muscles, causing a decrease or impairment of
the feeding rate. In consequence the energy available for
growth and reproduction will be reduced. At the cellular level
PAHs can alter fluidity and permeability of membranes and
cause disturbance in the structure and function of the
lysosomes, the organelle responsible to produce digestive
enzymes. Injury of lysosomal membrane occurs and the release
of hydrolytic enzymes leads to cell damage and possibly cell
death [2].
Some scientists have been studied
ways of recognising the origin of contaminants from their
distribution and predominance. Because these classes of
pollutants can have either a petrogenic or pyrolytic origin it
is a step forward in environmental chemistry to be able to
identify the source of pollution. Lower temperature generation
of PAHs leads to abundant formation of alkyl-substituted
compounds whereas high temperature processes generate mainly
unsubstituted compounds. This has been accomplished by
calculating some indices, the ratio of the relative
concentration of the typical pyrolytic 4,5-methylene
phenanthrene to the total concentration of methylphenanthrenes.
High values of this index gives indication that the sample has
formed in high temperature processes, while low values are
indicative of the presence of petroleum samples [3]. Another
index is the ratio of phenanthrene concentration to anthracene
concentration (P/A). Due to the high isomeric stability of
phenanthrene, high temperature processes such as combustion,
gives rise to P/A < 10, whereas slow maturation processes like
diagenesis originate P/A > 15. The ratio of fluoranthene
concentration to pyrene concentration can also give similar
information on the possible source of PAHs. If this index Flt/Pyr
> 1, the sample was pyrolytic generated, if Flt/Pyr < 1 it
indicates petroleum hydrocarbon signature [4].
A study was conducted at Aterro
Beach to evaluate the presence and extent of petroleum
contaminants, in particular (PAHs), in the sands and mussel
tissues. Samples were collected and analysed by standardised
methods and revealed high concentrations of these aromatic
compounds. The sixteen polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
measured monthly were: naphthalene (Nap), acenaphthylene (Acy),
acenaphthene/fluorene (Flu+Ace) phenanthrene (Phe), anthracene
(Ant), fluoranthene (Flt), pyrene (Pir), benzo(a)anthracene (BaA),
chrysene (Chr), benzo(b)fluoranthene (BbF),
benzo(k)fluoranthene (BkF), benzo(a)pyrene (BaP),
dibenzo(a,h)anthracene (dBA), benzo(g,h,i)perylene (Bpe) and
indeno(123-cd)pyrene (Ind) and 13 of these PAHs were present
in the sediments. Their concentrations varied in time in the
range 30-1200 ng·g-1 of sediment and the most abundant
compound was acenaphthylene (13-580 ng·g-1). The sum of PAHs
reached their maximum concentrations in July when the
sediments were black tainted in the streambed crossing the
beach. When these values are compared to the ones from a
reference site, these represent an increase of two orders of
magnitude relative to the reference. The molecular ratio Flt/Pyr
was calculated for sediments and it gave values less than 1
from May to July, suggesting petroleum hydrocarbons
contamination rather than pyrolytic contamination. Overall,
the levels of contamination in the sediments were high but
well below the values reported from harbour sediments of
extensive ship traffic (10-100 µg·g-1)[5].
In the mussel tissues from Aterro
Beach all the 16 PAHs under study were present in high
concentrations 3700-17000 ng·g-1. In the same way as we
compared the concentrations of PAHs in the sediments from a
contaminated site to a non-contaminated one, the comparison
between mussel tissues gave a different result. The difference
between clean and contaminated mussels is not so striking.
Mussels from the reference site had total concentration of
PAHs varying with time between 1500-6500 ng·g-1 of dry weight.
Although the highest concentration was considerably lower than
in the contaminated mussels, the magnitude of PAHs
concentrations in clean mussels is at most 10 times below that
of contaminated mussels.
The range of concentrations of
PAHs found in this study for mussels can be considered high
when compared to mussels living in polluted conditions of the
French coast where PAHs values range 60-370 ngg-1. The PAHs
accumulated in the mussel tissues is the result of several
routes of input including contamination from the sediments,
from the food particles and even from the water column. This
observation opens way for discussion on the importance of
assessing the contamination in the living organisms besides
the other elements of their habitat. It also stresses the need
to investigate early warning monitoring tools such as cellular
and molecular biomarkers to evaluate cellular damage prior to
higher level of organisation disruption.
References
[1] Raymond Chang, Chemistry,
1994. McGraw-Hill, Inc. 5th Ed.
[2] Usha Varanasi, Metabolism of Polycyclic Aromatic
Hydrocarbons in the Aquatic Environment, 1989. CRC Press.
[3] P. Garrigues et al., 1995. Polycyclic Aromatic
Hydrocarbons, 7, 275.
[4] P. Baumard et al. , 1998. Environ. Toxicol. Chem., 17,
765.
[5] S. E. McGroddy et al., 1996. Environ. Sci. Technol., 30
172.
Top |