By A . Grechko,
A. Fedyaev, V. Usenko, M. Cherepasky,
S. Kacemba, A. Zlebova, D. Ilkevitch, V. Khomitch.
In the article there is a
list of normative and methodical documents defining the
requirements to the protection and approaches to the
estimation of surface and underground water petroleum
contamination when storing and transporting oil and
oil-products worked out by the Central Scientific Research
Institute for Complex Development of Water Resources (CSRICDWR)
in late 90-ies. Study experience of soil, bottom, underground
and surface water petroleum contamination is generalized at
the typical objects: the former military base in Gomel
district, Cobrin oil-base, two parts of the oil pipe-line "Druzhba"
break and also the petrol station located in the third belt of
the sanitary protection zone of Minsk city water-intake "Zelenovka".
The main regularities of the lost petroleum migration in
different geological and hydro geological conditions are
defined. the complex of measures on contaminated soil
rehabilitation and surface and underground water refinement is
presented.The RB is
located in the Central part of Europe and takes a territory of
207,6 thousand km². Its population is 10 million people. There
are two oil-refining plants in the RB. On its territory there
are about 5 objects of petroleum storage (including about 4,5
thousand petrol stations), several oil and product pipe-lines
the length of which is over 10 thousand km. Besides earlier in
the RB there were military bases of the former USSR containing
big petroleum depots. The majority of the objects mentioned
were built in 60-70-ies and their equipment have mostly been
aged by the present time. In this condition natural petroleum
contamination has been widely spread.
Much attention to this problem
in the RB in contradiction to the Western and CIS countries
was paid in mid- 90-ies. At that time normative documents
stricter than earlier regulating the problems of natural
protection when building and using the objects of petroleum
storage were prepared and approved and methodical
recommendations defining the approaches to the estimation and
prognosis of surface and underground water petroleum
contamination were worked out. Directly by the CSRICDWR there
were prepared STB 17.1.3.06-2000. Natural protection.
Hydrosphere. Underground water protection from contamination.
General requirements; STB 17.1.3.05-99. Natural protection.
Hydrosphere. Underground and surface water protection from
contamination when storing oil and oil-products. General
requirements; the Temporary Regulations on ensuring ecological
security of petrol stations; the Methods of inventorying the
objects of petroleum storage and the form of the initial data
collection; the Methods of ecological inspection of the
functioning petrol stations and ecological grounding new oil
and product reservoirs and petrol stations; the Methods of
prognosis of contaminating substances migrations in the
underground water-carrying horizons; the Recommendations.
Minsk centralized system of dinking water supply. The measures
on the protection of the underground water-intake "Zelenovka"
from petroleum contamination. General requirements.
Parallel with this the Ministry
of Natural Resources and Natural Protection and its
subdivision - CSRICDWR made estimation and prognosis of
petroleum contamination at the concrete objects. For the last
5 years study data have been fulfilled at the former military
air base in Gomel district, Cobrin oil-base, the two parts of
the oil pipe-line "Druzhba" break and also at several being
reconstructed petroleum depots and petrol stations. The
research included: soil geological survey, test well boring
and soil testing; hydro chemical testing of rivers and
reservoirs; underground water selection and testing in test
and water operating wells; the prognosis of petroleum
migration in rivers and underground water; working out the
recommendations and measures on the petroleum contamination
centers localization and contaminated parts of the territory
rehabilitation.
The strongest center of
underground water petroleum (kerosene) contamination was found
at the former military base in Gomel district. The object is
located between the rivers Sozh, Iput and Ut. The upper part
of the hydro geological section, most exposed to contamination
is presented by a week water-carrying Dnepr moraine complex,
the power of which is up to 10-12m and by water-carrying
lowermidpleistocene water glacial complex the power of which
is up to 15m. The latter one is sufficiently widely used for
the purpose of water supply. The main sources of underground
water contamination are the three petroleum depots the
capacity of which is correspondingly 5, 10, and 15 thousand
tons each. Because of financial limitedness the research was
carried out only at the second petroleum depot with the
capacity of 10 thousand tons. As a result of boring of the 11
test wells there were discovered that the kerosene lens were
formed in the area of about 60 thousand m² in the weak
water-carrying Dnepr moraine complex on the surface of
underground water at a depth of from 4,05 to 7,9m. Its power
changes from 0,07 to 2,11m and in average is 1,1m. For the
average rock porosity equal to 30%, the volume of the lost
petroleum is about 29 thousand km². For a sandy rock water
output equal according to the literature data to 0,1 it is
possible to extract about 6,0 thousand m³ of kerosene from the
lens. Thus the lens of kerosene is a subject of a commercial
usage when carrying out the work on the rehabilitation of the
contaminated parts of the former military base. At the present
time the Institute is carrying out the work on contouring the
lens by the method of the vertical electric boring. It is
quite probably that the area and the volume will appear to be
more than it is discovered by test boring. On the RB territory
there are over 10 such military bases.
Cobrin oil-base examination
took place in its reconstructing connection. The oil-base is
located at Cobrin western outskirts 400m from the right bank
of the river Mukhavets and 450m from the left bank of the
channel Shevnya. The hydro geological section of the territory
being studied consist of the water-carrying Dnepr over moraine
water glacial complex and of the weak water-carrying Dnepr
moraine complex. As a result of the research made petroleum
concentration in soil is up to 62,2-129,0g/kg of dry bottom,
in bottom – 11,9-16,3g/kg and in underground water –
5,4-20,8g/l. The area of petroleum contaminated soil is about
30% and of contaminated bottom – about 50% of the oil-base
territory and is traced through a depth of 8m that shows
active petroleum migration with underground water. The
petroleum content is lessening with the depth. Its
concentration at a depth of 0,4m averages 1084mg/kg; 1m –
1270mg/kg; 2m – 762mg/kg; 3m – 518mg/kg; 4m – 212mg/kg; 5m –
95mg/kg; 6m – 72mg/kg; 8m – 50mg/kg. In the northern part of
the base there is a sector 4 thousand m² in area within which
there is a deposit of petroleum (diesel fuel) on the mirror of
the underground water in the form of the lens with the power
changing from 1 to 5cm. The prognosis of the petroleum
dissolved in underground water is made by the numerical
modeling method. It has showed the frontier of the petroleum
contaminated underground water with its concentration of
0,05mg/l that corresponds to the maximum admissible petroleum
content in the fish-industrial reservoirs will not reach the
river Mukhavets and the channel Shevnya even in 50 years. The
rehabilitation in the contaminated parts of the oil-base
include: the rehabilitation of the sectors with the high level
of soil contamination (500-2500mg/kg) using technical
recultivation methods – rather shallow (10-20cm) soil aeration
by means of regular soil layer ploughing up, soil liming, etc;
recultivation of the contaminated parts with the high level of
soil contamination (more than 2500mg/kg) using special
biopreparations of hydrocarbon microorganism destructors; a
regime observant well building.
The Institute has also examined
the consequences of the two breakdowns at the oil pipe-line “Druzhba”.
As a result of the first one and the petrol A-76 leak in
Corneev forest area, Gomel district the territory about 66,5ha
in area was contaminated. At the time of the examination the
maximum petroleum concentration in soil was 15300mg/kg of dry
bottom, in bottom – 482mg/kg and in underground water –
1,2mg/l. Bottom petroleum contamination was traced trough a
depth of 8m. Taking into account a considerable remoteness of
the breakdown place from residential areas, open reservoirs,
river sand water-intake wells rather slow petroleum migration
with an underground flow, moderate petroleum carrying out with
surface water, sufficiently high degree of the territory
self-purifying ability (evaporation, carrying out with
underground and surface water, absorbing by plants) and also
the fact that the territory is not used actively un
agricultural and other industry, the measures on the breakdown
liquidation were mostly directed to the strengthening of the
compensatory abilities of the territory (strengthening of the
washing regime and the highest water plants planting);
organizing control over the contamination center and carrying
out annually (in Summer) measures on hydrocarbon
biodestruction in soil bottom in the most contaminated parts.
As a result of the second breakdown a diesel fuel leak
happened and the territory 6ha in area was contaminated. By
this 9 horticultural plots were contaminated in different
extent. The minimum petroleum concentration in soil was
48mg/kg, maximum – 23290mg/kg. Bottom petroleum contamination
is traced through a depth of 10m. The petroleum concentration
at a depth of 0,9m averages 1397mg/kg; 1m – 1236,3mg/kg; 2m –
753,5mg/kg; 3m – 252,8mg/kg; 4m – 274,7mg/kg; at a depth of 5m
– 209,2mg/kg. At a depth of 7, 9 and 10m the bottom was tested
in three wells. The petroleum concentration has averaged
correspondingly 350,8; 166,6; 145,9mg/kg. The irregularity of
bottom contamination is caused by the peculiarities of the
territory hydro geological conditions (different depth of the
level bedding and seasonal inconstancy of underground water
infiltrative feeding) and litological structure of the plot
and is a result of the different petroleum transportation with
underground water in bottoms having different physic
mechanical and absorbing characteristics. Petroleum content in
surface water objects changes from 0,01 to 31,4mg/l.
Underground water in the part of the breakdown lies down at a
depth of from 0,7 to 1,1m. They are timed to concide to the
water-carrying upperonlake alluvial horizon. The petroleum
concentration in underground water changes from 0,1 to
4960,0mg/l. With the depth the petroleum concentration is
lessening. In the water-intake wells fitted out to a depth of
more than 12m the petroleum concentration changes from 0 to
1mg/l.
Taking into account a
settletive territory contamination by the second breakdown the
main aim of the measures is to lessen the total level of the
petroleum contamination of the plot ensuring manufacturing
ecologically clean agricultural production and preserving the
health of the people temporary residing there. For reaching
the goal it is necessary:
- to provide a washing regime
on the contaminated territory and that is especially
important - in the parts that are used in agricultural
manufacturing. This task can be decided at the expense of
the lowering the underground water level as a result of
carrying out hydro technical drainage melioration to a depth
of the root inhabited level, which is 1,0-1,5m.
- to exclude the territory
flooding by surface and underground water that is the main
factor of transporting contaminative substances (petroleum
in our case) from contamination center. This task can be
decided as a result of draining the underground water to
1,0-1,5m.
- to provide the
rehabilitation of the day surface of the contaminated
territory in order to create rather comfort conditions there
for people residing. This task can be decided in three ways
depending on the territory natural conditions and its level
of the petroleum contamination. The first way lies in
pouring in clean bottoms and can be implemented in those
parts that are used in agricultural activity. The second one
means to conduct technical recultivation by dint of
ploughing up a soil layer regularly and its liming, etc. It
can be implemented in the parts with rather low
contamination level. The third one is to recultivate soil
using special hydrocarbon microorganism destructors. It can
be implemented in the parts with a high contamination level.
- to provide haulage and
purification of contaminated underground water. Considering
the lost petroleum mostly masses in the upper part of the
bottom water-carrying horizon the task of the haulage of
contaminated underground water can be decided as a result of
the hydro technical drainage melioration with lowering the
underground water level to 1.0-1,5m. For purification
contaminated drainage water special systems catching
dissolved petroleum swimming on the surface are to be used.
By haulaging and purifying contaminated underground water
the problem of accumulating a part of drainage flow can
arise. It can be decided by creating in the upper level a
meliorative channel (in the area 200m in length from its
source that is a wedging zone of contaminated underground
water) of the accumulating capacity.
- to provide observation and
control over the nature condition. This task is to be decided
by creating permanent posts for observing petroleum content in
soil, underground and surface water. The order of carrying out
regime observations is defined considering natural conditions,
the level of the territory contamination and its structure of
engineering and technical natural protective measures.
A large number of measures of
big volume at the second breakdown section are explained only
by the fact that in summer period people live and are involved
in agricultural activity there. That is why as a result of the
contaminated land recultivation the necessary sanitary,
hygienic and ecological norms of nature conditions must be
provided there.
We can consider one of many
examples of underground water contamination in the petrol
station parts – when a petrol station is located in a sanitary
protective zone (SPZ) of a drinking water-intake. Such example
is Petrol Station №7 located in the third belt of the SPZ of
the water-intake "Zelenovka".
The water-intake "Zelenovka"
operates the water-carrying Dnepr and Sozh water glacial
complex. Within the examining part where the Southeastern wing
is located it is widely spread and is unsealed by the wells at
a depth of from 24,8 to 52,2m. Mostly the bedding depth of the
roof of the water-carrying horizon changes from 25 to 48m and
averages 37,8m. Water contained rocks are represented by sands
of different granulometric content in the section of which
sufficiently powerful seams of gravel and gravel material and
also lens and seams of rather waterproof sandy soils and loams
are often can be seen. In the base of the Dnepr and Sozh
water-carrying complex there are moraine sandy soils and loams
of the Dnepr frozenness the power of which is up to 18 and
more meters. In the roof of the water-carrying horizon there
is a thickness of the moraine deposit of the Sozh frozenness
represented by moraine sandy soils, loams and clays with the
seams and lens of sand of different granulometric composition
or gravel material. In the district of several wells clay
formation of the Sozh moraine in the section are completely
replaced by sand diversities, creating in closing thickness
litological "windows", favoring water overflowing from upper
lying horizons. Filtration factor according to the laboratory
research data is 3,1-3,5m³/24h. Filtration factor magnitude
found according to the data of building haulage changes from
9,21 to 29,02m³/24h. Water conductivity of the complex changes
from 500 to 1000m³/24h. Water abundanty of the complex is
characterized by the specific 1,3-12,2 l/s outputs.
Piezometric levels in the wells are installed at a depth of
14,9-15m that corresponds to the absolute notes of
201,82-201,84m. The average absolute note of the underground
water level at the period of the water-intake building was
205,4m. Thus there has been a little level shear for the time
of water-intake operating. Specific level lowering factor for
the last years has shown that a settled regime of underground
water filtration has been formed at the water-intake.
According to the regime observation data and the result of
modeling operating stocks of the water-intake are formed at
the expense of natural horizon stocks and drowing underground
water resources.
Complex research in accordance
with the present methodical documents was not carried out at
the object. That is why the petroleum contamination
characteristic of the part of the water-intake and petrol
station area is made by the materials of individual scientific
research works carried out in 1997 and 1999-2000. The works
give incomplete and fragmentary picture of the object
contamination. By characterizing petroleum contamination of
the object there was made an estimation of the petroleum total
content, volatile aromatic hydrocarbons (benzyl, toluene,
ethyl benzyl) and half volatile polio aromatic hydrocarbons (pyrene,
benzo(a)pyrene, phenanthrene, etc). In soil petroleum
contamination is discovered in the area of the petrol station
and adjoining territories to 50m in distance. Maximum total
petroleum content of soil is 18181mg/kg of dry bottom and
minimum one – 123,5mg/kg. In bottoms (including artificial
ones) petroleum contamination is discovered at a distance of
to 300m from the petrol station towards the water-intake "Zelenovka"
and at a depth of to 45m. Maximum total petroleum content of
bottoms has been discovered very close to the petrol station
at a depth of 12,2m. It is 10500mg/kg. With this volatile
hydrocarbon content is 1607mg/kg there. Minimum total
petroleum content of bottoms (3,3mg/kg) is discovered at a
distance of 70m to the South from the petrol station at a
depth of 7,5m. It is 1320mg/kg. At a depth of 44m total
petroleum content is 47,5mg/kg. With this it is important to
note that in the petrol station area sandy soil deposits of
the Sozh moraine damming operating water-carrying horizon are
fully contaminated.
At surface water objects (reservoirs, meliorative channels)
that are located at a distance of from 100 to 400m to the
South from the petrol station the total petroleum content
changes from 0,84 to 3.00mg/l. In underground water of "upper
water" type bedding at a depth 1,4-5,6m from surface petroleum
is discovered at a distance of 70-230m from the petrol
station. Its total content changes from 0,14 to 0,38mg/l. In
underground water bedding at a depth of from 12,0 to 16,0m
from surface petroleum is discovered at a distance of 70-300m
from the petrol station. Its total content changes from 0,04
to 0,36mg/l. The total volatile hydrocarbon content changes
from 0,661 to 3,846mg/l. In pressure water being operated by
the water-intake "Zelenovka" (the water-carrying Dnepr and
Sozh water glacial complez) petroleum is discovered at a
distance of 70-300m from the petrol station. At a distance of
70m from the petrol station its total content at a depth of
41,7m is 0,12mg/l. At a distance of 300m from the petrol
station its total content at a depth of 40,6m is 0,02mg/l. In
the operating wells of the Southeastern wing of the
water-intake "Zelenovka" underground water petroleum
contamination was not discovered by January 01, 2000.
The following measures making
for the protection of the water-intake "Zelenovka" from
petroleum contamination have been considered and estimated:
liquidation of the center of underground water petroleum
contamination, i.e. Petrol Station №7, contaminated soils,
bottoms and underground water in that area; installation of a
geomigrative screen on the way of the contaminated underground
water movement; optimization of a regime underground water
selection by the operating wells of the South-Eastern wing of
the water-intake "Zelenovka". These measures do not replace
the measures that are to be carried out in sanitary protection
zones of water-intakes according to BN&R (СHиП) 2.04.02-84 and
SanR&N (СанПиН) 10113RB99 and are additional.
Preliminary (on the level of
scientific ground) analysis of measure variants of the
water-intake "Zelenovka" protection from petroleum
contamination allows making the following conclusion:
- It is necessary to carry out
completely the measures on the contamination center
liquidation (Petrol Station №7 reconstruction) for the
water-intake "Zelenovka preservation;
- It is expedient to operate the
South-Eastern wing of the water-intake "Zelenovka" according
to the present water-intake scheme;
- The most effective and
technically acceptable measure variant of the water-intake "Zelenovka"
protection from petroleum contamination is to install a
geomigrative screen consisting of a water-intake well with
1000m³/24h output with the existing intake regime and
liquidation of the underground water contamination center (The
Petrol Station reconstruction);
- Working out technical and
economic ground of this measure variant should be considered
as a prior direction of the research.
The examples given show the essential petroleum contamination
of underground water in the RB and the necessity of its more
thorough examining in order to ensure a normative quality of
underground water.
Top |